Banana Bread Peanut Butter & Jelly
Back to all recipes

Banana Bread Peanut Butter & Jelly

Print Recipe

So this recipe is a lot more complicated than our usual ones, but it is absolutely worth the effort. However, you could just purchase a pre-made loaf of banana bread at the local bakery and then this recipe is cake (pun totally intended). 

Here's the thing though, we are better at spreading peanut butter onto things than actually making them ourselves, so here are a couple of links to some healthy banana bread recipes. Decide which one is most appealing to you and then come back here for further instructions.

Healthy Whole Wheat Flower Banana Bread From Cookie & Kate

Paleo Banana Bread from Paleo Running Mama 

Banana Bread Recipe with 5,000 reviews from All-Recipes 



  • HomePlate Creamy Peanut Butter
  • Jam of your choosing (we like strawberry)
  • A fresh loaf of banana bread


  • Cut off two thick slices of banana bread
  • Place them on a cookie sheet and into the oven at 425º for about 3 minutes, then flipping for another 3 minutes. Let it get a bit toasty, but not too toasty.
  • Let it cool for a second.
  • Spread your jam on one slice.
  • Spread HomePlate Peanut Butter on the other.
  • Place the jammed slice on top of the peanut butter slice.
  • Take a photo for the gram and tag @homeplatepb
  • Take a bite.
  • Take another bite.
  • Wipe your cheek, you got some peanut butter on it.
  • Take another bite.
  • Take your finger, pick up the crumbs and eat the last bits.